The Pensieve

An Academic Guide to Harry Potter

Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire

Written By: Dana Huff - Nov• 08•05

I just watched Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire for the first time.

Spoilery details follow…

I really, really enjoyed this film. I think it is the best of the Harry Potter films to date. The trio have become much better actors. Though some plot details were changed, I think this movie maintained the spirit of the book much better than the PoA movie did.

I really liked some of the changes that were made. I think in some cases, they tightened the story and actually made it better. For instance, Neville providing the gillyweed instead of Dobby was clever. I think it was a bit of foreshadowing for the next movie, when Neville will really break out and show us why he’s in Gryffindor.

My main quibble is that I didn’t get to see enough of the Quidditch World Cup at all. I really wanted to see that game. I suppose that would have added a good 10 minutes to an already long film, however.

It was interesting to hear Cho speak with a Scottish accent. Then again, I guess the books never made it clear where she was from. It could be Scotland as easily as elsewhere.

I didn’t think I was going to like Moody’s eye, but it was actually OK. Not how I pictured it, but OK. The courtroom scene in the Pensieve was great. I loved it. It was interesting to portray Barty Crouch, Jr. as wholly unsympathetic. That tongue-flicking thing that David Tennant did was really creepy. Actually, the film didn’t explain why Crouch, Jr. wasn’t in Azkaban, and I think they should have.

I don’t really like Flitwick’s new look at all. I didn’t realize that that was supposed to be him in the last film, but I finally put it together. He looks, frankly, like a pint-sized Hitler. For that matter, Crouch, Sr. was a little bit Hitler-ish, too.

I liked that the Death Eaters’ robes looked like Klan robes. I thought that was a clever touch and spot-on interpretation. I also liked the effects on the Dark Mark, both in the sky and on the arms of the Death Eaters. It was more frightening than I imagined.

Ralph Fiennes was frightening and brilliant. That whole graveyard scene was scary. I cried through most of it. It was so tragic. Actually, I really started crying when James told Harry what to do. That scene was amazing.

Miranda Richardson nailed Rita Skeeter.

Of course, the special effects were great. The dragon was amazing. I also liked the underwater scene with the merpeople. Voldemort’s regeneration was amazing.

I liked that the Weasley twins were finally given their due in a movie. In the books, they are so much funnier and have much more “on” time, and I always felt the movies shortchanged them. This one didn’t.

I was totally blown away. The movie was outstanding. Don’t throw rotten tomatoes at me, but I feel that if the book had been as tight as the movie, it would have been a better book. I have always considered it my least favorite of the series, but when I saw the movie, I realized what an excellent story it really told. I think it just needed some editing, maybe. (Ducks and runs.)

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. Both comments and pings are currently closed.